FMS EdgeFMS Edge — home

Guide

What are the advantages and disadvantages of Foreign Military Sales compared with Direct Commercial Sales?

Updated 26 October 2026Checked against the SAMM: 26 October 2026

Neither route is faster than the other in general. The U.S. Government is generally neutral between them, and the Department of War does not normally provide price quotes for comparing the two. The government-to-government relationship can be an advantage or a disadvantage depending on the purchaser.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of Foreign Military Sales compared with Direct Commercial Sales?

Under the partner buys from the U.S. Government in a government-to-government relationship, which some partners see as an advantage and others as a disadvantage, depending on the political climate; under Direct Commercial Sales it contracts with a U.S. company.

As a matter of policy, the U.S. Government is generally neutral between and Direct Commercial Sales, but by exception it may decide that select articles, services or technology go government to government to protect its most sensitive and sophisticated technologies [SAMM ].

Under , the international partner is entering a direct government-to-government relationship with the U.S. Government (). In fact, the international partner is purchasing directly from the . This arrangement can be viewed as either an advantage or a disadvantage depending on the political climate. Some international partners desire the association implied by the interaction. Other international partners, where the popular view of the United States is not as positive, may desire to distance themselves from the and enter into a Direct Commercial Sales () arrangement with a U.S. contractor. In this situation, public opinion may view a relationship with U.S. industry more favorably than the direct government-to-government relationship inherent in .

The is involved in approving both and . For , Department of State () approval is required for the [SAMM ]. The or the , or both, may also coordinate to approve or disapprove a request at any point between the purchaser’s request and the [SAMM ]. For , the contractor must apply to the to obtain an export license [SAMM ] []. In either method, the makes the final decision to authorize military defense sales [SAMM ].

Under the , both and must be notified to the U.S. Congress if the proposed sale meets or exceeds the statutory dollar thresholds [SAMM ] [, ]. The main difference in Congressional Notifications between and relates to the timing during the acquisition cycle. For , Congressional Notification occurs prior to the U.S. Government contracting with a U.S. contractor for the goods and prior to offering. For Direct Commercial Sales, Congressional Notification takes place following contract signing with the foreign party. Under the timeline to contract signing is shorter, which does not by itself mean a shorter delivery timeline.

Under Section 2(b), , the Secretary of supervises and directs all sales and exports of defense articles and services, and alike []. That direction includes whether a sale or export is made and whether it is delivered, so that sales and exports are integrated with other U.S. activities and best serve U.S. foreign policy []. This determination is made for in the licensing process and for in the internal coordination process of preparing a case. Although it rarely occurs, the always reserves the right to terminate a export license or an case and to halt the actual export deliveries of items or -licensed items when doing so is determined to be in the national interest of the United States.

Other relationship considerations are decisions of technology transfer and disclosure of classified information. Decisions on technology transfer and disclosure of classified information are also referred to as releasability decisions or releasability policy decisions. Under the policy of avoiding false impressions, personnel must not indicate to a potential purchaser that a sale is possible until they have considered releasability, disclosure, sanctions and all the coordination required [SAMM ]. Proposals that would lead to the disclosure of classified military information must be authorized in advance by the designated disclosure officials in the originating departments and agencies or by the National Disclosure Policy Committee [SAMM ]. Under , the Department of War (DoW) engages with the DoW technology transfer and disclosure infrastructure to support releasability for the proposed sale. Under a arrangement, industry precoordinates the requested scope of the license with the military departments or the releasability community when the request falls outside existing export policy allowances. Releasability reviews can be resource-intensive, both in terms of available experienced personnel with knowledge of the capability and system and funding of the manpower to support the review process. The availability of administrative funding for cases to support these reviews, including activities as requirements definition with the international partner, assessments, and differential capability analysis, among other activities, can be an enabler to support first-time exports of complex systems.

The process is executed by DoW civilian employees, DoW support contractors providing specialized assistance as needed (e.g., information technology), and active-duty U.S. military personnel. The direct involvement of DoW personnel in managing the procurement and delivery of an international partner’s programs leads to close communications throughout the case life as many day-to-day program issues are identified, evaluated, and resolved. This level of communication and personal interaction is often viewed as a catalyst for building stronger overall military-to-military relationships.

In programs, contractor personnel can be expected to be knowledgeable about their products. Defense contractors typically employ individuals who possess extensive experience with the DoW and often include individuals with prior active-duty-experience in the U.S. military. Despite this prior DoW experience, many international partners value the direct interaction with DoW civilian and active-duty U.S. military personnel offered through the process.

Care should be taken when comparing timelines under and ; neither nor are faster than the other in general, and many factors impact delivery timelines. The acquisition process involves the development, review, and acceptance of the case, plus the assembling of requirements for economic quantity or consolidated purchasing cycles as well as contract negotiations and production lead times. An individual international partner’s priorities are integrated into the overall DoW acquisition priority in the process.

By contrast, the system only involves contract negotiations and production lead times after the company obtains the export license. In general, industry prepares its proposal more quickly than the prepares the case. Under , the international partner negotiates its priority with industry. Industry may be capable of accelerating their processes for commensurate financial compensation. It is also possible that international partners with a well-developed purchasing capability can negotiate sales contracts more quickly than the DoW, which is bound to the structured process.

For secondary and support items, the DoW may maintain an inventory. In cases of an emergency for the international partner, if the materiel is available in DoW inventories, it may be possible for the international partner to achieve faster delivery through shipment from DoW stocks or through the diversion of items that are under production for the DoW. Contractors normally do not produce items in anticipation of sales and generally do not maintain an extensive inventory of defense articles.

International partners frequently desire to compare the total cost to the total cost. As a matter of policy, the is generally neutral as to whether a partner purchases U.S.-origin defense articles or services commercially or through [SAMM ]. The DoW does not normally provide price quotes for comparing to [SAMM ]. It is difficult to predict whether employing the system or direct commercial channels would be more or less expensive for any particular acquisition. The differing contractual pricing and financing approaches, as well as variations in the total package content, make cost comparisons between and quite difficult.

Unless the has determined that a specific item or service will only be offered via , there are few absolutes that dictate all countries should select exclusively either or commercial channels for a given purchase requirement. Rather, there are many considerations, unique both to the individual international partner and to the items being procured, that are involved in such a choice. In fact, in comparing the system to the system, the decision regarding a potential procurement has a range of possibilities other than just choosing between two separate options: traditional or traditional . The question of whether to procure via or ultimately involves a decision by the international partner about how much procurement responsibility they are willing to assume and how much they are willing to entrust to the DoW.

Offsets offer a mechanism for the international partner to use a major defense acquisition to obtain other domestic benefits for the international partner’s nation. Offset agreements can occur in conjunction with international partner-funded cases, but non-repayable Foreign Military Financing () credits may not be used to pay any costs associated with offset agreements [SAMM ].

Price, support package and cash flow

An case provides estimated prices and estimated payment schedules, and the final price of an item or service generally will not be known until after it is delivered [SAMM , ]. prices, by contrast, typically provide a fixed price with a fixed . U.S. industry may profit under . Depending on the negotiated contract structure, U.S. industry may assume losses on a sale. U.S. industry could structure a contract such that the international partner assumes any additional charges over the final price, protecting U.S. industry from losses. Flexibility under allows for U.S. industry to weigh potential profit gains against potential losses.

Direct Commercial Sales can allow for more flexible contracting because U.S. industry is not required to adhere to the same regulatory requirements as the U.S. Government. International partners may wish to participate actively in tailoring the procurement process by fixing delivery schedules, negotiating fixed prices, including special warranty provisions, and ensuring that designated penalties are stipulated for contractor failure to comply with the contractual agreement. Other flexible arrangements that may be negotiated into might include a used-equipment trade-in or a sale involving a barter arrangement as partial payment.

For , the international partner can acquire support from the instead of placing its own personnel throughout the United States. It is possible for the international partners to purchase contract administrative services for a under a separate case with the [SAMM ].

Under the system, the ensures that the purchaser can obtain the support articles and services, such as support equipment, spare parts, training, and publications, required to introduce and sustain the equipment [SAMM ]. In , the contractor may also develop a support package for the primary item. Depending on the factors used to develop these support packages, the actual content of the support packages may differ. There may be significant cost differences in the offer versus the proposal, even though both contain the same type and quantity of primary items.

In , contractors achieve cost savings by offering other than DoW military standard configurations. Any deviations from typical DoW configurations could limit interoperability and follow-on support from the DoW. The cost savings achieved in the initial acquisition of a nonstandard DoW configuration may be quickly outweighed by the added cost of sustaining a nonstandard system.

In situations where two or more manufacturers are competing for the international partner’s business, contract prices may be less than prices. This may be possible because the manufacturers may be willing to agree to fixed prices that are below the normal profit margins allowable under DoW contracting regulations. Price advantages under may also be possible during times of rapid inflation in the U.S., especially if the contractor has the ability to make quick deliveries from rapid new production.

The process has the potential to offer lower contract prices, primarily through larger quantity buys achieved by grouping DoW and multiple requirements into a single procurement. Additionally, the DoW may already have priced contracts in place for the DoW that can potentially support new requirements. Typically, the DoW has procured the same or similar items under other contracts. With this knowledge and experience, the DoW may be more informed in the negotiation process.

Under the , the shall obtain certified cost or pricing data only on concluding that none of the regulation’s exceptions applies, and the regulation sets a dollar threshold for obtaining that data []. Certified cost or pricing data is an important factor in ensuring that a fair and reasonable price is being paid for the articles or services under a contract.

Direct commercial contracts can call for a relatively large down payment, payable at the time of contract signature. The size of such down payments varies with circumstances and the level of contractor risk. For cases, the required at the acceptance of an can be lower than commercial contract down payments. For items with a substantial production period, the phased progress payment system used for may distribute the payment burden beyond the payment requirements of commercial contracts. These possible differences in payment terms should be evaluated as part of the international partner’s procurement decision.

One special feature of the system involves the potential use of cross-leveling agreements. Cross-leveling agreements allow international partner funds which are on deposit in the to be moved to and from special holding accounts or moved between separate cases, thereby maximizing the use of the international partner’s funds. Two methods can accomplish cross-leveling. In the first method, international partner financial personnel conduct their analysis to provide cash transfer direction to the . In the second method, the international partner authorizes the , by a written agreement, to conduct automatic cross-leveling to balance funds requirements among all cases. Cross-leveling is in contrast to direct commercial contracts, which stand alone and typically provide for fixed prices with fixed payment schedules but with no provision for the movement of funds between individual contracts. In short, cross-leveling under provides the advantage of flexibility to the international partner to meet changing requirements.

The requires a charge for a proportionate amount of any non-recurring costs () of research, development, and production of sold through []. This requirement is not imposed on [SAMM ]. It is up to industry to decide how much of the industry Internal Research And Development (IRAD) costs to shift to the international partner. For systems or capabilities in the U.S. inventory, the Research and Development (R&D) investment can only be recouped under via . The same system or capability sold under would not result in a recuperation of U.S. taxpayer R&D investment dollars.

However, for international partners desiring to purchase via , a provision exists to potentially waive the application of under [SAMM ].

For , the price includes the base cost that the paid for the item or service plus the other authorized charges necessary to recover the full cost to the [SAMM , ]. Although the does not make a profit from , the price paid to DoW contractors does include a fair and reasonable profit for the contractor. However, the amount of contractor profit is limited by the provisions of the . The full contract cost, including contractor profit, is paid via the .

Conversely, the profit ceiling for commercial contracts is established by the marketplace. The international partner will not normally have access to information that reveals how much general and administrative costs or overall contractor profit is included in a direct commercial contract. U.S. firms typically add administrative costs as part of their equipment unit prices, whereas administrative costs are identified as a separate item on the agreement.

Follow-on support, training and classified items

An important consideration in the purchase of U.S. defense articles involves the nature of the follow-on support required from U.S. sources. If the items being purchased are also being used by the U.S. military and are known to require substantial logistical, technical, and training support, the purchase may offer support advantages. permits the international partner to capitalize on U.S. experience and existing logistics inventories and training facilities. If items are not available from the DoW spare parts inventory, the DoW logistics structure serves as procurement staff for the international partner by procuring required individual items from the current U.S. sources. Additionally, the supply support arrangement offers an effective means to replenish in-country spare and repair parts.

Some U.S. contractors are also capable of providing full logistics support for the items that they sell. Corporate reputations depend on good performance, and where contractors can furnish such support, the results can be expected to be as stated in their contracts.

The DoW may provide follow-on support for end items acquired through [SAMM , ]. However, the DoW’s ability to support items may be limited when equipment configurations differ. Also, if the manufacturer only uses commercial part numbers to identify items without cross-referencing to DoW national stock numbers, support will be greatly complicated, and support delays may result.

The DoW also has dedicated staffs and in-country Organizations () to facilitate the administration of [SAMM ]. The also supports the marketing efforts of U.S. companies, while maintaining strict neutrality between U.S. competitors [SAMM ]. For activities, the supports and coordinates with the commercial attaché whose role is predominately facilitating U.S. industry’s marketing phase rather than aiding in program execution.

Nonstandard items are those systems or capabilities that differ from the U.S. configuration. systems or capabilities are items that are not DoW Programs of Record and may include nonstandard items. Standard items can become nonstandard items as the DoW phases out certain items, models, or configurations and replaces them with other items, models, or configurations.

For nonstandard items and difficult-to-support standard items, the may use a Commercial Buying Service () when DoW organic capability or contractual supportability is unavailable or not timely. Existing options include the Parts and Repair Ordering System () and the [SAMM ]. support for nonstandard systems or components is usually provided via an case. Sustaining goods can be challenging under because of the lack of existing logistics infrastructure in place to support items that do not have a DoW Program Office. In general, may have more flexibility in providing support for nonstandard items. The international partner should consider how much responsibility and visibility they desire when procuring a item, versus utilizing the infrastructure to obtain oversight and efforts in transparency.

Training is a central element of successfully operating and maintaining today’s high technology military equipment. The DoW has established training resources to support its own training needs. Under , international partners can access many of these training resources. Although the DoW does acquire contractor training in certain circumstances, some types of military training are simply not available through commercial sources, such as access to the DoW’s unique training ranges. On the other hand, the international partner might need some form of tailored training not available from the DoW.

Classified items can be procured through either or unless otherwise specified by the Government-to-Government-Only (G2G-Only) list or otherwise restricted from export. Transportation of classified goods procured under needs to be coordinated through the . The same national security and foreign policy reviews will take place regardless of whether classified items are procured through or .

References

SAMM

Public authorities

  • AECA §38: Arms Export Control Act of 1976, as amended, §38 (22 U.S.C. §2778)
  • AECA §36(b): Arms Export Control Act of 1976, as amended, §36(b) (22 U.S.C. §2776(b))
  • AECA §36(c): Arms Export Control Act of 1976, as amended, §36(c) and (d) (22 U.S.C. §2776(c) and (d))
  • AECA §2: Arms Export Control Act of 1976, as amended, §2 (22 U.S.C. §2752), Coordination with foreign policy
  • FAR 15.403-4: Federal Acquisition Regulation 15.403-4 (48 CFR 15.403-4)
  • AECA §21: Arms Export Control Act of 1976, as amended, §21 (22 U.S.C. §2761)

Related